Critiques of the Red-Brown Commission

Page on the Commission is here


Holocaust Survivors expressed grave concerns about the Commission at its inception in 1998. As PDF.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


Sir Martin Gilbert resigned in 2008:


SEE NOW:

THE ‘GENRE’ OF ‘HOLOCAUST STUDIES’  PROFESSED BY THE COMMISSION’S DIRECTOR GENERAL / EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR (His speech at the Lithuanian Parliament on 30 June 2011)

and…

Simon Wiesenthal Center statement (Jerusalem 1998)

Efraim Zuroff (Vilnius 2001)

Efraim Zuroff (Jerusalem 2005)

Efraim Zuroff (Jerusalem 2007)

Jewish Community of Lithuania and Uni0n of Former Ghetto and Concentration Camp Prisoners (Vilnius 2008). Letter contains the text:

‘The fact that the “International Commission for the Evaluation of the Crimes of the Nazi and Soviet Occupation Regimes in Lithuania” established by the President (chaired by E. Zingeris), did not publicly defend its own member Yitzhak Arad, or the other Jewish anti-Nazi partisans, is also surprising.’

Jewish Community of Lithuania and Uni0n of Former Ghetto and Concentration Camp Prisoners (Vilnius 2008)

Karen Sutton, professor of history at Touro College in New York, in her The Massacre of the Jews of Lithuania (see Recent Books → 2008; Background →  2008):

‘Despite a number of half-hearted measures and ill-conceived historical commissions, contemporary Lithuania has much soul-searching to do to come to terms with what happened [....]‘ (p 209); ‘Both the historical commission and the lethargy of the Lithuanian Department of Justice on the issue of alleged war criminals have elicited an enormous outpouring of opposition from the Lithuanian Jewish survivor community and — “symmetrically” — tacit approval of the general non-Jewish population’ (p 211).

Yad Vashem (Jerusalem 2008)

Geoff Vasil (Vasiliauskas) (Vilnius 2008)

Valdas Vasiliauskas (Vilnius 2008);  English translation


Professor Dov Levin demanded removal of his name in 2008:


Avi Friedman (Jerusalem 2009)

Dovid Katz (Vilnius 2009a)

Dovid Katz (Vilnius 2009b)

Shimon Samuels (Paris 2009, presented at Warsaw); alternate link

Jonathan Freedland (London 2009)

Clemens Heni (Berlin 2009)PDF

Esther Goldberg (London 2010)

Dovid Katz (Vilnius 2010);  in Russian translation

Dovid Katz (Vilnius 2010b)

Dovid Katz (Vilnius 2010c)

Bildungswerk für Friedensarbeit e.V. (2011)


Professor Konrad Kwiet resigned in 2011:


NOTE: Criticism of the political campaigns waged by the commission does not imply negation of individual accomplishments by teachers, researchers, event organizers and others who may have cooperated with it over the years, or of the commission’s earlier series of academic publications.

Return to Top

Comments are closed.